Police Blotter
Cortez Police Department incident reports from Nov. 12 through Nov. 18: a driver taken into custody after a crash that hit a median and two street signs on East Seventh Street, a DUI arrest on Livesay Drive, an assault arrest after a man was bitten during a fight on South Washington Street, and four trespassing summonses at City Market.

A driver whose car hit the center median, a curb and two street signs on East Seventh Street near L Way late Thursday, Nov. 12, was found a short time later sitting behind the wheel of the heavily damaged car in a nearby apartment parking lot and taken into custody, according to Cortez Police Department reports.
The following items are drawn from 15 incident reports released by the Cortez Police Department for Nov. 12 through Nov. 18. An arrest, summons or citation is an accusation, not a conviction, and everyone named is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court. The Cortez Current will update a blotter item when it learns that charges were dismissed or a case was resolved; anyone named can send documentation to news@cortezcurrent.com.
Thursday, Nov. 12
2:48 p.m., East Montezuma Avenue and North Fillmore Street. An officer stopped Steven Yellowhorse, who was walking on East Montezuma Avenue, and arrested him on a Cortez Municipal Court warrant for failing to appear for arraignment on a trespassing charge, in case DC261384. He was served with the warrant at the jail.
4:05 p.m., 508 E. Main St. (City Market). An officer who was in the store’s parking lot on another call stopped Takoda Blueeyes as he walked out the front doors. Dispatch confirmed that Blueeyes had been barred from City Market indefinitely in 2022, according to the report, and he was issued a municipal summons for trespassing.
10:55 p.m., East Seventh Street and L Way. An officer sent to a report of damaged signs in the roadway found tire marks, car parts and pieces of signs on East Seventh Street. An off-duty sheriff’s deputy told him he had heard a crash a few minutes earlier. The officer concluded that a westbound car had hit the center median, a curb and two street signs, and matched part numbers on the debris to a Honda Civic, according to the report. He found a Civic with heavy front-end damage, four flat tires and a deployed airbag in the parking lot of a nearby apartment complex, with Xavier Silas in the driver’s seat. The officer reported smelling alcohol on Silas, who said at first that he did not know what crash the officer meant, declined roadside sobriety tests and was taken into custody. He turned down an examination by medics and at the emergency room, and he was issued a summons and booked into the jail. The report does not list the charges on the summons; it says the car’s registration had expired and that Silas’ license was revoked and he had no insurance.
Friday, Nov. 13
7 a.m., 730 E. Driscoll St. (Montezuma County Detention Center). An officer served a person already held at the jail with two Montezuma County Combined Courts warrants and returned later in the morning to serve a third. The Cortez Current is not naming the person because all three warrants carry juvenile-court case numbers.
4:15 p.m., 500 block of East Montezuma Avenue. An officer patrolling the north side of City Market saw two men run from the sidewalk into the front yard of a neighboring home and appear to throw things into the bushes, where he found a bottle of vodka and two small bottles of Fireball whisky, one of them open, according to the report. Carlos Collins Jr. was arrested, and after a medical clearance at Southwest Memorial Hospital he was served at the jail with a municipal summons for possession of an open alcohol container.
Sunday, Nov. 15
11:50 p.m., first block of South Washington Street. A caller reported that a man had come into a residence and started a fight with someone who lives there. A resident told the officer that Jason Culpepper came in yelling and got in his face, that he pushed Culpepper away, and that Culpepper bit him twice as he tried to hold him down; the officer saw a bite wound on the man’s arm, according to the report. Culpepper told the officer the other man had attacked him. The officer concluded Culpepper was the primary aggressor and arrested him. After a medical clearance at the hospital, Culpepper was booked into the jail on a summons for third-degree assault.
Monday, Nov. 16
7:46 a.m., 1100 block of Cochita Drive. Officers were called to a domestic disturbance at a home. Another resident showed an officer phone video of Dahlia Davis kicking a locked bedroom door and yelling, and the officer found the trim pulled away from the door frame and damage around the latch, according to the report. Davis told the officer the room was her office and that she had been trying to get her papers and belongings out of it. After the officer consulted the district attorney’s office, Davis was arrested and booked into the jail on a summons for harassment and criminal mischief.
12:10 p.m., 730 E. Driscoll St. (Montezuma County Detention Center). An officer served warrants on three people at the jail: Dennis Orange, in case 26T115; Byron Atene, in cases 25T18 and 26T138; and Natasha Billsie, in case 26M5046.
1:25 p.m., 730 E. Driscoll St. (Montezuma County Detention Center). An officer served Matthew John at the jail with a Montezuma County Combined Courts warrant, in case 25CR41.
4:24 p.m., 730 E. Driscoll St. (Montezuma County Detention Center). Arletto Lameman turned himself in at the jail and was served with a Montezuma County Combined Courts warrant, in case 26T4.
9:28 p.m., 900 block of Livesay Drive. An officer was sent to check on a car that had been parked outside a home for more than 30 minutes and found Marcus Stanley Jones in the driver’s seat with the engine running. The officer reported smelling alcohol on Jones, who said he had been drinking, and noted signs of impairment on roadside sobriety tests, according to the report. He was arrested at about 10:07 p.m. and declined to choose a blood or breath test under the state’s express consent law. After a medical clearance at the hospital, he was booked into the jail and served with a summons for driving under the influence.
10:31 p.m., 303 S. Broadway (Popeyes). Officers were called about a man hitting vehicles at the restaurant. A driver told an officer that Carlos Collins had kicked his vehicle’s bumper and struck its window and had also hit the restaurant’s drive-thru window; the driver said his vehicle had no visible damage, according to the report. Collins kept walking away when the officer called his name and told him to stop, and the officer took him to the ground and into custody in the neighboring Family Dollar parking lot. After a medical clearance at the hospital, Collins was booked into the jail on a summons for interfering with an officer and disturbing the peace.
Tuesday, Nov. 17
1:08 p.m., 508 E. Main St. (City Market). The store’s asset protection officer reported that Edwin Lehi was inside despite a trespass notice issued a year ago that runs through Nov. 20. An officer found Lehi in the store, had him leave and issued him a municipal summons for trespassing, with a court date of Nov. 30. Lehi told the officer he had only come in with another person and was about to leave, according to the report.
10:30 p.m., 1311 N. Mildred Road (Southwest Memorial Hospital). Officers called to the emergency room about an injured woman learned that the man who had driven her there, Kalayo Benally, is barred by court protection orders from having contact with her, according to the report. Benally told an officer he had come across her by chance at a gas station and took her to the hospital because she asked him to. He was arrested in front of the hospital just after midnight for violating a protection order and, after a medical clearance, booked into the jail on a summons.
Wednesday, Nov. 18
2:43 p.m., 508 E. Main St. (City Market). An officer sent to a report of a man and a woman in the roadway near East Main and North Harrison streets who looked as if they were about to fight found the pair outside City Market, where the man said no fight had taken place. Dispatch reported that he, Bryan Ponzo Jr., had an active Cortez Municipal Court warrant, in case DC2612559; he was arrested and served with it at the jail. While the officer was there, Keithn Summa walked into the store’s parking lot and yelled at Ponzo, according to the report. Dispatch then found that City Market had given Summa a trespass notice in February 2025 that does not expire. A sergeant arrested him nearby, and after a stop at the hospital he was served at the jail with a municipal summons for trespassing.
Eleven of the 15 reports say they were drafted with Axon’s Draft One software from the officer’s body-camera audio and reviewed by the officer.