Sheriff's Blotter
Montezuma County Sheriff's Office incident reports from Oct. 11 through Nov. 17: a man flown to Grand Junction after a dog bite, cut brake lines on a pickup, a deputy kicked and spat on during an arrest and a $2,500 gift-card scam that borrowed a real officer's name.

A man bitten on the face, neck and arm by a dog at a property off Road J.6 was flown to Grand Junction for specialized treatment last month, and the dog’s owner was issued a summons for unlawful ownership of a dangerous dog, according to a Montezuma County Sheriff’s Office report released Wednesday. The dog had never been vaccinated against rabies and was placed under quarantine, the report says.
The following items are drawn from 29 incident reports released by the Montezuma County Sheriff’s Office on Nov. 18. Most cover Nov. 5 through Nov. 17; four deal with earlier incidents, going back to Oct. 11. An arrest, summons or citation is an accusation, not a conviction, and everyone named is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court. The Cortez Current will update a blotter item when it learns that charges were dismissed or a case was resolved; anyone named can send documentation to news@cortezcurrent.com.
Sunday, Oct. 11
1:36 p.m., 10400 block of Road 25. The regional credit manager for a concrete supplier reported that a check written by a contractor’s company for concrete delivered June 17 to a job site in Mancos had been returned, leaving about $9,842 unpaid. She told a deputy the contractor had said he would pay by the end of July but never did, though the homeowner had paid the contractor in full. In the report, written Oct. 28, the deputy wrote that he would seek an arrest warrant on a felony charge of fraud by check; the report does not say whether one has been issued.
Monday, Oct. 19
10:15 a.m., 12300 block of Road 26. A man reported that a credit card company had written to tell him someone applied for a new card in his name, weeks after his Amazon account was broken into and cards stored on it were used without his permission. The next day he received a letter about a second card he had not applied for. A deputy documented the case and told him to keep reporting it at identitytheft.gov, which federal investigators may use.
Sunday, Oct. 25
11:53 a.m., 18300 block of Road 27, near Dolores. Someone got into several trucks, mostly diesels, parked at a shop lot sometime over the previous few days and tried to siphon fuel from them, according to the report. The deputy found a pin-sized hole in the fuel tank of a 2017 Dodge 2500, with a broken-off siphon hose still inside; its owner estimated about 10 gallons of diesel, worth roughly $63, were taken, and said he would try to repair the tank himself rather than replace it, which would cost $500 to $1,000. The lot’s cameras had been out since a lightning strike, and recent heavy rain left no useful tracks. There are no suspects.
Tuesday, Oct. 27
12:39 p.m., 29100 block of Road J.6. A deputy arrived behind an ambulance at a home where a man had been bitten by a dog on the face, neck and arm. The dog’s owner, Christina Marie Shulte, who lives on the same property, told the deputy the dog had been locked in the house when she left for work and she did not know how it got out; she said the dog is fine with her but does not like other people, especially men, according to the report. The dog had received only parvo and distemper shots and had never been vaccinated against rabies, and Shulte signed a quarantine agreement. The man, who told the deputy he wanted to press charges, was flown to Grand Junction for specialized treatment, and a physician’s report noted serious bodily injury. Shulte was issued a summons for unlawful ownership of a dangerous dog.
Thursday, Nov. 5
10:51 a.m., 7000 block of Road 22.9. A woman reported that she had been scammed after applying for a job with a company she found through the Signal messaging app. The people she dealt with had her withdraw about $4,950 from her bank account, buy Bitcoin with it through Cash App and send it to them, saying they would use it to buy office supplies for her new job, according to the report. Her bank later told her she owed it another $4,450. The deputy told her to notify her bank, change the passwords on her financial accounts and file an online fraud report.
3:39 p.m., 7200 block of Highway 160/491. A deputy sent to a report of a fight separated a man and a woman who had been arguing over a lost wallet. The man said the argument never turned physical, but the woman, Fercinda Gould, told the deputy she got upset and kept pushing him, according to the report. Dispatch said an active protection order bars Gould from harassing contact with the man and from having weapons. She pulled a container of pepper spray from her pocket during the contact, and the deputy found two folding pocketknives on her and a third in her backpack. Gould was booked into the Montezuma County Jail on charges of harassment, domestic violence and violation of a protection order.
Saturday, Nov. 7
11:46 p.m., Highway 160 and Road C. A sergeant who heard about a crash between a car and a cow found a Mitsubishi Outlander resting on the fog line and a large black cow against the guardrail across the highway. A woman at the scene said she had been driving, and a Colorado State Patrol trooper took her into custody after roadside tests, according to the report. A witness’s written statement then said a man in a blue shirt had been driving, and the people from the car gave conflicting accounts. The trooper decided not to make an arrest because it could not be proved who was driving. No one asked for medical attention, and the Colorado Department of Transportation removed the cow.
Sunday, Nov. 8
1:14 p.m., Road G and Highway 160/491. An off-duty sergeant came upon a two-vehicle crash. A deputy cleared debris from around a vehicle that was blocking the southbound lane so it could be moved, and stayed until the highway reopened. The Colorado State Patrol investigated the crash.
Monday, Nov. 9
9:26 a.m., 2279 Hawkins St. (field behind the Baymont). A deputy sent to help with people camping in the field found John James in a tent. James told the deputy he had an active warrant, and dispatch confirmed it and said he had already been barred from the property. He was booked into the Montezuma County Detention Center on a Cortez municipal warrant for failure to appear in a trespassing case and was issued a summons for third-degree trespassing.
11:14 a.m., 9600 block of Road G. A man told a deputy that a caller from an unknown number said he was under investigation for numerous crimes and that his bank account would be frozen, and that he could put $2,500 on gift cards so he would have money in the meantime, according to the report. He did, and after the caller had him send the cards to “verify” them, the money was taken. The caller also said a Cortez police officer, giving the name of a real officer, would contact him; when the man called that officer, the officer knew nothing about it. The deputy told him the name most likely came from the Police Department’s website, which lists its officers, and that real law enforcement would not ask to see gift cards. The man’s bank is trying to recover the money. There are no suspects, and the case has been closed.
2 p.m., 100 block of North Fifth Street, Dolores. Sheriff Steve Nowlin received a written complaint and two photographs from the Dolores town manager about a dog that keeps running loose in violation of town ordinance. The photos were taken the morning of Nov. 6. Nowlin wrote that he would contact the dog’s owner, who has been warned before, and issue a summons.
4:13 p.m., 8200 block of Road 46, near Mancos. A caller reported a suspicious person in a private gated residential community. A deputy found David Liukko lying in a ditch, saying he was cold, and tried to find him somewhere to stay for the night, according to the report. The deputy saw knives, a multi-tool and an ice pick on the ground near Liukko, and dispatch reported an active protection order that bars him from having firearms or other weapons. Liukko was arrested and booked into the Montezuma County Jail on a charge of violating a protection order; he told the deputy he did not know the order was still active or that the items counted as weapons. When the items were logged into evidence, the deputy found they included one fixed-blade knife, an ice pick, a multi-tool, a small razor-blade tool and a screwdriver handle he had at first taken for a second knife.
Tuesday, Nov. 10
10:50 a.m., 7900 block of Road 26.5. A deputy met Cortez Police Department detectives who were with Dana Blood, who had an active warrant from a Cortez Police Department case for failure to comply, case 26T292. Blood was arrested and booked into the Montezuma County Jail.
12:54 p.m., 20000 block of Highway 491, Lewis. A red Ford Focus left the southbound side of the highway, went down a hill and through barbed-wire and wooden fencing into a pasture. Firefighters were treating the driver when the deputy arrived, and he was taken to the hospital. The deputy found nothing in or around the car that pointed to a cause and noticed no odor of alcohol or marijuana, according to the report. The Colorado State Patrol investigated the crash. The deputy wrote that his body-worn camera did not record his arrival because he had not turned it on.
1:14 p.m., 22600 block of Road L. A man reported that when he tried to drive his Ford F-250 for the first time in about three days, the brake pedal went to the floor, and he found the brake lines had been cut. The deputy saw a brake line hanging down on the front passenger side and wrote that the lines appeared to have been cut cleanly. The man’s camera, which points toward the truck, did not capture anyone cutting the lines, and he said he could not think of anyone who would do it. The deputy estimated the damage at $119 to $486 before labor. There are no suspects, and the case has been marked inactive.
8:09 p.m., 25800 block of Highway 491, Pleasant View. Gary Strand, who told a deputy he knew about his warrant and had planned to turn himself in, was booked into the Montezuma County Jail on a Cortez Police Department warrant for failure to appear, case 26M293.
10:03 p.m., 5900 block of Highway 160. A deputy backed up a Colorado State Patrol trooper on a traffic stop for a possible drunk driver. After roadside tests, the trooper arrested the driver, Wendy Laner, for driving under the influence and took her to the Montezuma County Jail, according to the report. A passenger and the car were released to a woman who came to the scene.
Wednesday, Nov. 11
7:32 a.m., Highway 184 and Road P.8, near Mancos. A deputy responded to a crash in which a car hit a deer. The driver had already called for a ride and a tow truck, and the Colorado State Patrol took over the investigation.
6:49 p.m., Highway 184 and Road 23.5, Lewis. Deputies responded to a two-vehicle crash that the caller believed was intentional. The people in a Dodge pickup said a sedan that had been following them came up fast, tried to pass and deliberately hit the back of the truck as they slowed to turn onto Road 23.5; the sedan’s driver said the pickup braked suddenly ahead of her and then turned into her car on purpose, pushing it into a ditch, according to the report. Deputies could not determine who was at fault or whether it was intentional and found that no crime had been committed. The Colorado State Patrol asked everyone involved to file crash reports online.
Thursday, Nov. 12
6:02 a.m., 700 block of Railroad Avenue, Dolores. A deputy and Sheriff Steve Nowlin went to an apartment after a caller reported possible domestic violence. The deputy wrote that the allegation was unfounded, based on what people at the scene said and what deputies saw. Casey Finnestead, who acknowledged he had an active warrant, was arrested on a San Miguel County warrant in a third-degree assault case, 26CR12, and booked into the Montezuma County Detention Center.
8:10 a.m., 730 E. Driscoll St. (Montezuma County Detention Center). Jessica Lynn Koontz, who was already in custody at the detention center, was served with an arrest warrant for failure to comply, case 26M15.
11:26 a.m., 865 N. Park St. (county court building). Felicity Jones was arrested in court for violating her bond conditions. A deputy took her to the jail, where she was booked on a charge of violation of bail bond conditions in case 26M291.
Friday, Nov. 13
3:04 a.m., 27700 block of Highway 184, near Dolores. A caller reported a man with a broken-down vehicle who was looking for a ride, and a second caller reported that the same man, Jett Neal, had taken her two dogs and was going to take them to the pound. A deputy found Neal walking along Highway 184 with a gas can and gave him a ride back to his vehicle, where the two dogs were in the back seat. Neal said the woman had agreed to let him take them; she told the deputy she had not, according to the report. The deputy also wrote that an active protection order bars Neal from a home where he had been staying. Neal was arrested and taken to the Montezuma County Detention Center; the report gives a summons number but does not list the charges.
11:37 a.m., 28200 block of Highway 160. A woman reported that two cordless drill sets, a DeWalt and a Milwaukee worth $488 in all, were stolen overnight from the bed of a pickup that was parked out of view of a camera. The truck bed’s cover does not lock. Both drills are covered in white paint, and she has alerted local pawn shops; the deputy said he would contact pawn shops in neighboring towns.
2:47 p.m., 7200 block of Highway 160/491. Charles Fish was arrested on a failure-to-appear warrant in a case charging theft of $300 to $1,000 and giving false information to a pawnbroker, case 26M22. He was booked into the Montezuma County Detention Center.
Saturday, Nov. 14
10:12 a.m., 17000 block of Road 30, near Dolores. A minivan went partway down into a ravine off the southbound side of the road. A passerby had pulled the driver out and was helping her up out of the ravine when the deputy arrived, according to the report; he helped get her out and had her sit in his patrol car, out of the bad weather, until medics checked her. The Colorado State Patrol investigated the crash, and the deputy then drove the driver home.
Monday, Nov. 16
9:43 a.m., 19800 block of Road 21.4, Lewis. Deputies sent to a report of people with active warrants staying on a property found Tristian Perez and Tonya Lindsey in a camper and arrested both, according to the report. Perez was booked into the Montezuma County Detention Center on Dolores County warrants in several cases, with charges including possession of a dangerous weapon, violation of a protection order, resisting arrest, reckless driving, identity theft and fraud by check, and on a Montezuma County warrant in a case charging third-degree assault, false imprisonment and child abuse. Lindsey was booked on a Montezuma County warrant in a vehicular eluding case, 25CR224.
Tuesday, Nov. 17
12:25 a.m., 21000 block of Road S. Deputies were called to a disturbance at a home, where they found Malea McNeley being held down in a hallway, according to the report. McNeley had active arrest warrants and was placed in a patrol car; the people at the home said they did not want to press charges over the disturbance. The deputy wrote that McNeley said she had slipped out of her handcuffs, and that after deputies put them back on and he was buckling her into the patrol car, she spat in his face and kicked him repeatedly in the stomach, chest and hips. After a stop at Southwest Memorial Hospital for medical clearance, she was booked into the Montezuma County Detention Center on a Cortez municipal warrant and a Montezuma County warrant, case 26T275, and was issued a felony hold on charges of second-degree assault on a peace officer and resisting arrest.
6:12 a.m., 730 E. Driscoll St. (Montezuma County Detention Center). A deputy was told of a Nov. 12 fight between two inmates in one of the jail’s housing units. Jail video shows the two arguing over a lunch tray before Ramon Armando Paredes pushed the other man against a wall with his chest and punched him in the face, and the two grappled before separating, the deputy wrote; the other man also struck Paredes. The other man said he was punched several times and that his eye had been swollen. Paredes was issued a summons for third-degree assault.
The Montezuma County Sheriff’s Office released these reports to the Cortez Current in response to a public records request.