💧Boil water: Mancos Rural Water customers. The town's own advisory is lifted.Details
Schools

RE-1 board OKs Manaugh roof patch, picks search firm on 4-3 vote

The school board approved a $6,376.56 patch to stop water getting into the Manaugh Building while it decides the building's future, hired Hazard, Young, Attea & Associates to run the superintendent search on a split vote, and told its lawyers to seek a retrial in the Matthews HVAC case.

A wide view across the Manaugh Building's flat black rubber roof, with rooftop units and vents, trees and houses beyond, and the mountains under a clear blue sky
Photo: Montezuma-Cortez School District RE-1File photo: The Manaugh Building's flat rubber roof, in one of the district's photos of the building in the school board's Oct. 20 meeting packet.

The Montezuma-Cortez School District RE-1 board of education voted 6-1 on Tuesday to patch the leaking roof of the Manaugh Building for $6,376.56, a repair the interim superintendent described as a stopgap to keep water out while the district works out what to do with the building.

The board, which had been asked to approve the patch on the posted agenda, also hired a firm to run its superintendent search on a 4-3 vote and directed its lawyers to seek a retrial in the Matthews HVAC lawsuit. The meeting began at 5 p.m. and ran until just before 10 p.m., including two closed sessions.

Manaugh: a patch, not a repair

The agenda recommended a quote from Farha Roofing for $6,376.56. Interim Superintendent Drew Pearson told the board the district had two quotes, the other for about $27,000, and that the larger one dealt more with the roof’s perimeter, which he said would belong in a real roof repair if the district goes that way. Neither quote comes with a warranty, he said, and if the roofer finds problems it did not expect, further work would be billed by the hour or the day.

“This is just a stop gap measure,” Pearson said. The patch will not fix anything between the roof decking and the rubber membrane, he said; it is meant to stop water entering the building so there is no further damage inside, and to give the district time to make a more informed decision.

The district’s maintenance staff told the board the roof drains toward the center hallway, the curbs around rooftop equipment are torn, and the rubber membrane is past its life and keeps pulling away as it expands and contracts with warm days and cold nights. Staff said the patch should work, but he could not say for how long. The cheaper roofer walked the roof with district staff against a scope of work the district wrote; the other company priced its quote from photographs and did not do a site visit, which staff said explains most of the difference.

The district’s insurer will not pay for the roof, the board was told, because it is past its life, but would cover damage inside the building, such as mold cleanup, above a $10,000 deductible. Pearson said the district may not file a claim at all. Left as it is over the winter, staff said, moisture in the wooden decking under a load of snow could eventually threaten the roof. Testing for asbestos would be a first step whether the district later demolishes or remodels the building, Pearson and staff said; the district is gathering what the building is worth and what it would cost to tear down. The board heard at its Nov. 3 work session that its insurer would not pay for a new roof.

Asked about security, staff said the building has cameras and still sees some break-ins through windows, and that what remains of value inside is secured in the gym. The vote was 6-1; the recording does not identify the no vote.

Superintendent search: HYA, 4-3

The board approved a proposal from Hazard, Young, Attea & Associates (HYA) to run the 2026 superintendent search. A note on the agenda from Danielle Brafford, the district’s executive director of finance, said HYA met the criteria in the district’s request for proposals, with scoring by Brafford, Tracy and Nelson.

Pearson said he took no part in the selection to avoid a conflict of interest if he decides to apply for the job. He said he had also asked another administrator who might apply to step back from the scoring, and that Brafford then scored the proposals independently.

Board members split in the discussion. One preferred McPherson & Jacobson, saying it has done more work in Colorado and costs less; Pearson said feedback he had heard about the district’s past use of that firm “has not been the best.” Another member liked JG Consulting best. One member questioned whether the district needs a search firm at all, saying past searches with outside firms had not produced lasting hires. Others said a firm can handle the community outreach the board does not have time to build itself, and one member said a member of the Ute Mountain Ute Tribal Council had asked for the tribe to have a voice in choosing the next superintendent. Pearson said that if he were hired, he would be the district’s sixth superintendent since 2020, counting an interim team of three. The motion passed 4-3; the recording does not say who voted which way. The board heard from the search firms at its Nov. 3 work session.

Matthews HVAC: a retrial

The board met in closed session from 5:03 to 6:06 p.m. for legal advice on the Matthews HVAC litigation, under the state law that allows it. Later, it voted unanimously on a motion to “direct our attorneys to do a retrial and proceed as discussed.” Nothing more about the case was said in public, and no findings were described.

Other decisions

  • Grants. The board unanimously accepted two LOR Foundation grants for sound system equipment: $4,500 for the Montezuma-Cortez Middle School band and $9,950 for the Montezuma-Cortez High School choir.
  • Consent agenda. Approved unanimously, including minutes, the monthly employment lists, two high school student fee forms, the consulting contract with School Food and Wellness Group LLC after attorney revisions, and an intent letter for a $6,000 LOR Foundation grant application for a middle school Pursuits class.
  • Audit extension. Approved unanimously for the 2025-26 audit. Pearson said the auditors could not finish in time because some information was missing, mostly from the charter schools; one board member noted the district also used an extension last year.
  • Unified Improvement Plan. The district’s 2026-27 plan passed 6-1 after Director Mike Lynch pointed out sections of the state form without measures and targets and said none of the district’s strategic plan goals were written into it. Pearson said the data could be added, and gave as an example a gap of about 18 percentage points between the district’s third- through fifth-grade scores and the state average, which he said the district would aim to halve each year over two years. Only the district plan was voted on; the middle school and Mesa Elementary plans listed on the earlier agenda were not on the final one.
  • First Tee. The board approved the First Tee youth golf program for district PE classes, including the donations and materials in the building-level partner agreements, 6-1. As the vote was read into the record, Lynch voted no and the other six members voted yes.

The appeal in the transgender sports lawsuit, which the board tabled in October and which appeared on the earlier version of this agenda, was not on the final agenda, and the board did not take it up.

No one turned in a ticket to speak during public comment. At the end of the meeting the board went into closed session at 8:48 p.m. on a personnel matter, Pearson’s evaluation, and came back at 9:55 p.m. to adjourn without taking any action.

The board’s next work session is Tuesday, Dec. 1, and its December meeting is Monday, Dec. 14, at the district office, 400 N. Elm St.

Source: Montezuma-Cortez School District RE-1, board of education regular meeting of November 17, 2026, meeting video, and the final agenda on the district’s Diligent Community portal. Dollar figures for the roof and grants are from the agenda; the second roofing quote, the insurance deductible and the test-score figures are as staff stated them at the meeting. Students are not named.

Related coverage

More from News